The following is my translation of the notes and useful applications for the Epistle Reading for the Commemoration of the Lutheran Reformation (Reformation Day), Romans 3:19–28, as they are found in Das Weimarische Bibelwerk (1877). Square brackets indicate my own notes and additions. For the useful applications, I recommend the reader see this very helpful article by Dr. Benjamin T. G. Mayes.
II. The conclusion of the previously led disputation, that, namely, neither Jew nor Gentile know righteousness with works of the Law, because they both trespass the Law. (v. 9–23)
III. Proof that righteousness comes from faith. (v. 24–31)
Annotated Text
19. But we know (as those born Jews, to whom was entrusted what God had spoken, Romans 3:2), that whatever the Law (the Scripture of the Old Testament) says, it says to those who are under the Law (who belong to the Jewish polity);1 so that every (Jewish and Gentile) * mouth be stopped (that no one can boast of their own righteousness, but rather must humble himself before God and recognize His inborn, as well as actual sin), and all the world be accountable to God (that all men in the entire world confess that on account of their sin are subject to the righteous judgment of God and eternal condemnation).
1 And either have received it in written manner, or have it inscribed onto their heart by nature (Romans 2:15); for here the saying is of the Law which pertains to all the world.
* Psalm 107:42; Ezekiel 16:63; Galatians 3:22 (1 Kings 8:46)
20. Therefore,1 that no flesh (no man, be he Jew or Gentile) * by works of the Law (which are done according to the Ten Commandments) may be justified (nor can be declared righteous before God) by Him (the Lord, his God); for (now after the fall into sin) through the Law (grasped in the Ten Commandments) comes (only) knowledge (and anxious feeling) of sin.
1 Greek: Alternatively, “Thus it follows…” [διότι]
* Galatians 2:16; Psalm 143:2 (Romans 7:7)
21. But now (in the New Testament) the righteousness which counts before God is without doing the Law (and its works),1 is revealed (in the Gospel, as a high hidden mystery) and (yet previously) is testified through the * Law (of Moses) and the Prophets.
1 Greek: “the righteousness of God” (which He Himself provides and bestows, also which He only accepts as pleasing to Him and allows to count before His judgment).
* John 5:46; Acts 10:43 (Genesis 15:6, 22:18; Isaiah 53:11; Jeremiah 23:6)
22. Now I say of such (fully counting) righteousness before God which then comes through faith in Jesus Christ to all and upon all, when they believe (because faith is the only means through we grasp and appropriate to ourselves the promised righteousness won by Christ; but God reckons it to the one who believes in this manner).
(Philippians 3:9)
23. For * there is here (between Jews and Gentiles) no distinction;1 they are † altogether sinners (Luther: “Mark this when he says, ‘they are altogether sinners,’ for this is the chief point and the middle place of this epistle and of all of Scripture, namely, that all is sinful which is not redeemed through the blood of Christ and reckoned in faith. Therefore, grasp this text well, for here lies underneath all works, merit, and boast, as he himself says here, and there only remains purely God’s grace and honor”), and lack the glory which they ought to have before God (namely, the increated holiness and perfect inherent righteousness),
* Romans 10:12; Galatians 3:22, 28
1 Greek: “Because” [γὰρ]
† 1 Kings 8:46 (Romans 3:19, 11:32; Colossians 3:11)
24. and are justified * without (their own) merit from His (from God’s) grace (and pure sheer mercy), through the (perfect) redemption, which has happened through Jesus Christ;
* Ephesians 2:8
25. Whom God has set forth (and ordained from eternity) for a * mercy seat (of which the type was the mercy seat, that is, the cover over the Ark of the Covenant in the Old Testament, Exodus 25:17; because Christ has reconciled us with God and covered our sin which was committed against the Ten Commandments), through faith in His blood (through His blood, which He poured out for us as an atoning sacrifice), that He might demonstrate (and bestow) the righteousness that counts before Him, in that He forgives sin which has previously remained under divine forbearance1 (Luther: “Sin could neither be taken away by the Law nor by any good work; it had to be done by Christ and by forgiveness;” therefore, also in the Old Testament the sins of believers were forgiven solely and only for the sake of the coming Messiah);
* Leviticus 16:15; Hebrews 4:6 (Acts 13:38ff.; 2 Corinthians 5:19; 1 Timothy 2:6; Titus 3:5ff.; 1 Peter 1:18; 1 John 2:2ff.)
1 Greek: Alternatively, “As proof of His (earnest) punishing righteousness, because He had previously (in the Old Testament, until Christ, Hebrews 9:15) allowed committed transgressions to pass by, Romans 3:26, under divine (great) forbearance (so that one might think that God did not consider sin to be great; indeed, I say once more), as a (clear) proof of His punishing righteousness in this (appointed by divine wisdom) fitting time (since Christ, the guarantor, has born the wrath and completely expiated it).”
26. in order that He might at this time (the world in which the Son came in the flesh, and carried out the work of redemption) demonstrate1 (and bestow) the righteousness which counts before Him (by which we can stand before Him); so that He alone may be righteous (that He might be recognized by everyone as righteous, just as He alone is good, Matthew 19:17, and truthful), and make2 righteous the one who has faith in Jesus (who holds fast to Christ with true faith).
(Romans 4:5)
1 Greek: “show” [πρὸς τὴν ἔνδειξιν] (offer to all the world)
2 * “Nevertheless also,” or according to the Greek, “also in that He makes righteous” [καὶ]
27. Where * now remains boasting (of one’s own righteousness, as if a man could earn heaven from God the Lord)? It is over1 (and terminated. With such an alien righteousness bestowed purely out of pure grace, it has no place). Through which law (or teaching)? Through the works of the Law (through the teaching which requires works according to the Holy Ten Commandments in us and from us)? Not in this way (for then man would have a reason to boast of it, Romans 4:2), but rather through the law of faith (through the doctrine of the Holy Gospel, which requires faith in Christ for righteousness, and therefore teaches that by our own righteousness we cannot stand before God).
* Romans 2:17, 23; 1 Corinthians 1:29, 31 (Romans 8:2; Ephesians 2:8–9)
1 Greek: “excluded” [ἐξεκλείσθη]
28. Therefore * we now maintain (and infallibly conclude), that a man (be he Jew or Gentile) is (spoken) righteous (before the judgement of God) without works of the Law, only1 through faith (in Christ).
* Galatians 2:16ff (Acts 13:38)
1 Although this little word is not expressly found in the Greek text, nevertheless the manner of speaking of the German language requires such a contrast, which also agrees with Paul’s clear words, “as only” (Galatians 2:16), Christ’s procedure (Matthew 4:10; cf. Deuteronomy 6:13), and finally also the example of the Latin common Bible itself (Leviticus 31:2).
Useful Applications
II. DOCTRINE: That all men, none excepted, are sinners, and thus no one can be justified through works of the Law, since they are imperfect and tainted with sin. (v. 20–23) III. DOCTRINE: That we are justified without merit, by God’s grace, through the redemption which has happened through Christ Jesus, by faith in Him. (v. 24–25) DOCTRINE: That when boasting of worthiness before God has been struck down, thereby joy unto thankfulness is all the more awakened, along with all humility. (v. 27–31)
PATTERN OF SOUND WORDS 